Monday, March 26, 2012

THOUGHT OF THE DAY IN CONTEXT: Gertrude Stein Said TMI Can Cause Loss Of Common Sense

From time to time, I like to check out daily quotations and thoughts of the day - usually at the handy website. The oft-frustrating thing about such quotations, however, is that they often epitomize the out-of-context problem that I have with so much of today's news reporting. (One of the primary issues that I try to address with this Arizona's Politics blog, actually.) So, an innocent 30-second trip to quote-of-the-day territory will often kick off a mini-research and learning adventure. Occasionally, I will try to post those findings here.

Today's Thought of the Day on comes from American writer/poet Gertrude Stein:

"Everybody gets so much information all day long that they lose their common sense." - Gertrude Stein

Sounds like it comes from today's society. Only we know that Stein is no longer with us. So, it cried out for some digging. I found that it came from a short piece she wrote (or spoke) shortly before her death (1946). It was published after her death in the Yale Poetry Review:

Gertrude Stein, "Reflection on the Atomic Bomb" (1946)
They asked me what I thought of the atomic bomb. I said I had not been able to take any interest in it.
I like to read detective and mystery stories. I never get enough of them but whenever one of them is or was about death rays and atomic bombs I never could read them. What is the use, if they are really as destructive as all that there is nothing left and if there is nothing there nobody to be interested and nothing to be interested about. If they are not as destructive as all that then they are just a little more or less destructive than other things and that means that in spite of all destruction there are always lots left on this earth to be interested or to be willing and the thing that destroys is just one of the things that concerns the people inventing it or the people starting it off, but really nobody else can do anything about it so you have to just live along like always, so you see the atomic [bomb] is not at all interesting, not any more interesting than any other machine, and machines are only interesting in being invented or in what they do, so why be interested. I never could take any interest in the atomic bomb, I just couldn't any more than in everybody's secret weapon. That it has to be secret makes it dull and meaningless. Sure it will destroy a lot and kill a lot, but it's the living that are interesting not the way of killing them, because if there were not a lot left living how could there be any interest in destruction. Alright, that is the way I feel about it. They think they are interested about the atomic bomb but they really are not not any more than I am. Really not. They may be a little scared, I am not so scared, there is so much to be scared of so what is the use of bothering to be scared, and if you are not scared the atomic bomb is not interesting.

Everybody gets so much information all day long that they lose their common sense. They listen so much that they forget to be natural. This is a nice story.

Gertrude Stein, 1946

[first published in Yale Poetry Review, December 1947]
(as cited on this University of Pennsylvania page)

Not sure I agree with the late Ms. Stein that it displays a loss of common sense to be interested in the development and proliferation of new weapons of mass destruction. But, it is certainly food for thought, and it certainly is of interest (to me, anyway) to learn the context of her quote.

We welcome your comments about this post. Or, if you have something unrelated on your mind, please e-mail to info-at-arizonaspolitics-dot-com or call 602-799-7025. Thanks.

No comments: